The legal battle between Manchester City and the Premier League over alleged financial violations could have massive consequences for both sides, no matter the verdict. The hearing began on Monday, and the stakes are high for all involved.
The final outcome could set a precedent, as City firmly maintain their innocence regarding all allegations of financial misconduct. However, if found guilty, the club faces the possibility of severe penalties, including relegation. On the other hand, if City is exonerated, it could raise serious concerns about the Premier League’s governance and the validity of the charges brought against the club.
Some experts believe the timing of the charges, which were filed in February 2023, was a strategic move by the Premier League to demonstrate its ability to self-regulate, especially with the potential introduction of a Government-backed independent regulator. Recently, a high-ranking MP has provided updates on the progress of this proposed watchdog.
Regulator to be Introduced Within ‘Weeks’
If the Premier League loses the case, it could fuel further support for the establishment of an independent regulator, as it would suggest the league had acted without sufficient evidence. The Premier League is reportedly against the idea of an independent regulator due to the loss of power it would entail.
However, the arrival of the Government bill for a regulator may be imminent. Lucy Powell, Leader of the House of Commons, indicated on BBC’s Question Time that it could be just “weeks” before the legislation is officially approved. She stated, “In a few weeks’ time we are bringing in a football regulator – which the Premier League and many others absolutely don’t want us to do.”
Agents ‘Preparing Exit Plans’
In the event that Manchester City is found guilty and expelled from the Premier League, agents of some City players are already exploring their options. A report from the Daily Mail suggests that player representatives are evaluating what steps to take if their clients are forced to leave due to the club’s potential expulsion.
The commission overseeing the case has the authority to recommend relegation if serious violations are confirmed. The accusations revolve around illicit funding, lack of cooperation, and breaches of both UEFA and Premier League financial rules. Agents are reportedly waiting to hear about Manchester City’s contingency plans should the club be expelled. Speculation has even emerged that Real Madrid may attempt to sign midfielder Rodri if the club faces such drastic consequences.
Man City ‘Risk’ Expulsion from All Competitions
According to The Telegraph, there is also a risk that Manchester City could be banned from not just the Premier League, but from all competitions, depending on the severity of the verdict. The report cites rules that could lead to expulsion from cup competitions if the club loses its league status.
It’s unclear how this would affect their participation in European tournaments under UEFA. Despite these threats, Manchester City has repeatedly claimed to possess “a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence” that they believe will prove their innocence and fully exonerate them from any wrongdoing.
