Here’s a fresh take on the player ratings article, keeping it interesting and engaging:
Manchester City’s Top Performers So Far: Who’s Shining and Who Needs to Step Up?
The 2024/25 season may still be far from trophy time, but with over 10 matches played, Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City squad is already showing who’s thriving and who’s lagging. As City push forward in their pursuit of silverware, some stars are stepping into the spotlight, while others are struggling to make an impact. Here’s a rundown of the key players so far this season, based on their performances.
Standout Stars: Haaland and Lewis Lead the Pack
Erling Haaland and Rico Lewis are emerging as the standout performers for City, helping guide the Blues through the early stages of their campaign. Meanwhile, players like Nathan Ake, Oscar Bobb, and Kaden Braithwaite haven’t had enough game time to warrant a rating. But for the rest of Guardiola’s squad, here’s how they’ve fared so far.
Ederson – 7/10
Despite some summer uncertainty, Ederson has reaffirmed his position as the go-to goalkeeper with strong performances and some crucial saves.
Ortega – 6/10
Mostly a spectator, though he’s had some time in the Champions League. Not much to critique yet.
Rico Lewis – 8/10
This season feels like Lewis’s breakout as a regular starter. He’s capitalized on nearly every opportunity and proven he belongs.
Kyle Walker – 4/10
While Lewis shines, Walker’s struggles have been apparent. He’s been responsible for several conceded goals, raising concerns about his form.
Ruben Dias – 7/10
A consistent performer in defense, jumping right back into action after the Euros. A steady presence at the back.
Josko Gvardiol – 7/10
He’s been strong going forward but has had a few defensive hiccups. Nonetheless, Gvardiol’s availability and versatility remain key.
John Stones – 6/10
Still finding his rhythm after the Euros. Stones has been slower to get going, leaving fans waiting for his usual form.
Manuel Akanji – 8/10
Arguably City’s best defender this season. Composed and growing in confidence, especially in his advanced roles with Rodri absent.
Rodri – 6/10
A huge loss for City after his injury, just when he’d made his way back into the squad. City will surely miss him.
Mateo Kovacic – 7/10
While no one can truly replace Rodri, Kovacic has been solid in midfield, doing well under the circumstances.
Matheus Nunes – 5/10
Missed chances in starts against Watford and Slovan Bratislava. Needs to do more to stake his claim for a regular spot.
James McAtee – 7/10
Limited minutes, but his goal against Slovan Bratislava could be the confidence boost he needs to push for more game time.
Kevin De Bruyne – 6/10
A bright start, but injuries have kept him sidelined for five games, raising concerns for the rest of the season.
Ilkay Gundogan – 5/10
Back from Barcelona, but not quite the same. He’s still finding his feet, with Guardiola openly pushing him for more.
Bernardo Silva – 7/10
Versatile and effective. Silva has contributed more assists than any other City player, filling in wherever Guardiola needs him.
Kian O’Reilly – 6/10
A work in progress. Guardiola is experimenting with him in deeper roles, and O’Reilly is learning quickly, though patience will be key.
Jeremy Doku – 7/10
A few standout moments, including a fantastic goal against Fulham, but he still needs to refine his decision-making and final-third play.
Savinho – 7/10
An exciting start to his City career, with Guardiola trusting him to make smart decisions. Promising signs ahead.
Phil Foden – 5/10
Not the same Foden who dominated last season. Illness has impacted his form, and he’s yet to regain his spark.
Jack Grealish – 7/10
Back to his best, running at defenders and keeping City’s attacking tempo in check. A marked improvement from last season.
Erling Haaland – 9/10
Ten games, 11 goals. Haaland continues to prove why he’s one of the best, combining his goal-scoring prowess with some excellent team play.
The Verdict
City’s journey this season has been a mix of brilliance and uncertainty, with key players like Haaland and Lewis excelling while others, like Walker and Foden, struggle to find their rhythm. With a long season ahead, there’s plenty of time for improvement, but as things stand, City’s top performers are leading the charge for another shot at glory.
