Live Report: Could Sam Darnold Make a Stunning Return to the New York Jets?
The New York Jets traded away quarterback Sam Darnold during the 2020 offseason, but five years later, there’s growing speculation about a reunion in 2025. Leading the charge is ESPN’s Bob Wischusen, who passionately advocated for Darnold’s return during an appearance on 880AM ESPN New York, even after a rough postseason finish for Darnold with the Minnesota Vikings.
Wischusen’s Bold Pitch for Darnold
Wischusen didn’t hold back in expressing his hopes:
“Oh, I hope it crushes his market to the point that the Jets are the only team that can get their hands on him and then bring him here—1000%.”
The ESPN commentator laid out a scenario where the Jets capitalize on Darnold’s recent struggles to secure him at a bargain price:
“I would get every minion that I could muster if I were the Jets to put every whisper in everyone’s ear saying, ‘Did you see Sam last night? He was terrible.’ Then see if you can get his price down to the low $20 million range, sign him to a five-year contract, and bring him here tomorrow.”
Wischusen emphasized that he’d have no issue with Darnold as the Jets’ starting quarterback next season, adding:
“I hope nobody wants him after last night’s game and I hope the Jets have a chance to bring him back.”
What Would Darnold Cost the Jets?
If the Jets pursued Darnold, it would likely require the largest contract in franchise history. The current record belongs to defensive tackle Quinnen Williams, who signed a four-year, $96 million deal averaging $24 million per season.
Wischusen suggested a five-year deal worth around $100 million, averaging at least $20 million annually. However, Spotrac’s market value analysis projects Darnold’s free agency price much higher—around $160 million for four years, averaging $40.1 million per season. That figure would place him among the top 12 highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL.
The disparity stems from Darnold’s poor finish to the Vikings’ season. Despite Minnesota’s strong offensive performance early in 2024, averaging 25 points per game, the team faltered in Week 18 and the wildcard playoff game, scoring just nine points in both contests. Darnold’s individual struggles during those games were notable: 11 sacks, a 53% completion rate, one touchdown, one interception, and 411 total passing yards.
Darnold’s Career Year Despite Setbacks
While the season ended on a sour note, Darnold’s overall performance in 2024 was the best of his career. He threw for 4,319 yards, completed 66.2% of his passes, and boasted a 35-12 touchdown-to-interception ratio.
The Vikings finished with a remarkable 14-3 record, becoming the first 14-win wildcard team in NFL history. If Darnold had posted these numbers with the Jets, he would have shattered franchise records for passing yards and touchdowns in a single season.
Wischusen defended Darnold’s potential:
“Obviously, he showed this year that once you get him good players, he is a good quarterback, and you can win.”
Why the Jets Should Consider Bringing Darnold Back
Darnold’s first stint with the Jets was widely criticized, with many blaming the team for failing to surround him with adequate protection and playmakers. Now, the Jets boast a solid offensive line and talented weapons like Garrett Wilson and Breece Hall, creating a much more favorable environment.
Wischusen believes the circumstances have changed dramatically:
“The situations with the Jets and Panthers that he was in were very difficult hands to be dealt. Now, he’s shown he can thrive when given good players.”
The Jets’ Quarterback Conundrum
As the Jets face continued uncertainty at quarterback, a reunion with Darnold could be a compelling option. The 27-year-old quarterback has grown since his time in New York, and with a more complete roster, the Jets might be able to rewrite their shared history.
Will the Jets make the bold move to bring Darnold back? With free agency looming, the clock is ticking, and fans will eagerly await the team’s next step. Stay tuned for updates as this intriguing possibility unfolds.
