Julian Alvarez’s departure from Manchester City has been one of the biggest transfer shocks of the summer, as the Argentine joined Atletico Madrid for a record fee. The move, driven by Alvarez’s desire for more regular first-team action, has left many pondering whether this was an unexpected decision or the inevitable outcome of growing frustrations.
Despite being a key player last season—where he made more appearances than any other City player—Alvarez’s ambition for more significant roles in crucial matches led him to seek greener pastures. Pep Guardiola’s advice to carefully consider his future didn’t seem to sway Alvarez, who, two weeks later, accepted Atletico Madrid’s lucrative offer and left the Premier League champions.
Guardiola’s reaction was a mix of surprise and disappointment. He had encouraged Alvarez to contemplate his role and future at the club, but the response from the player hinted at deeper discontent. Alvarez had previously expressed dissatisfaction with his position, indicating he was often benched for critical games despite his efforts and adaptability in various roles.
In an April interview with MEN Sport, Alvarez admitted he preferred playing as a number nine but was willing to adapt. “I played more this season, and I’m happy with that,” he said, though his dissatisfaction was evident. He had shown impressive performances when stepping in for injured teammates, yet remained on the bench during key finals, including the Premier League finale and FA Cup final.
Comments from teammates such as Bernardo Silva and Kyle Walker have suggested Alvarez’s talent was underutilized. Walker criticized Guardiola’s decisions, noting Alvarez’s potential was often overlooked in crucial moments. “Sometimes, he probably should have played when he didn’t,” Walker commented, reflecting the belief that Alvarez deserved more significant opportunities.
Alvarez’s decision to move to Atletico Madrid represents a gamble. While he’s assured more regular playing time, it remains to be seen if he’ll feature in the high-stakes matches he craved. City, having pocketed £64 million from the transfer, will now focus on their new squad dynamics.
The exact nature of Alvarez’s discontent with Guardiola remains unclear, as he notably left Guardiola out of his farewell messages. What’s certain is that Alvarez’s departure marks a significant shift for City and raises questions about whether they might rue letting a potentially transformative player slip through their fingers.
