Lindsay Gottlieb Questions Late Replay Decision After South Carolina Defeats Southern Cal 89-85
Southern Cal head coach Lindsay Gottlieb expressed frustration with a crucial fourth-quarter video review after her team suffered an 89-85 defeat against No. 1 South Carolina on Sunday at Bon Secours Wellness Arena in Greenville.
The controversial sequence occurred during the closing seconds, when officials overturned an out-of-bounds decision following a successful challenge by Dawn Staley.
The reversal gave South Carolina possession with a two-point advantage and significantly changed Southern Cal’s final offensive opportunity.
Although Gottlieb acknowledged the difficulty of the decision, she questioned how the review affected her team’s timeout situation.
“It’s a tough call,” Lindsay Gottlieb said postgame Sunday.
How the Controversial Replay Changed the Game
With approximately 18 seconds remaining, South Carolina held an 87-85 advantage when Southern Cal’s Jazzy Davidson stole the ball from Jordan Lee near the top of the key.
The turnover created a transition opportunity for the Trojans, with JuJu Watkins receiving possession and driving toward the basket for a potential game-tying layup.
However, Lee recovered defensively and blocked Watkins’ attempt.
The ball went out of bounds, and officials initially awarded possession to Southern Cal with 15.6 seconds remaining.
Gottlieb immediately used a timeout to organize what she expected would be an opportunity to tie the game or potentially take the lead.
But during that stoppage, South Carolina challenged the out-of-bounds ruling.
Following an extended video review, officials determined there was “clear and conclusive evidence” that Watkins, rather than Lee, had touched the ball last.
The decision reversed possession and returned the basketball to South Carolina.
The change forced Southern Cal to foul Tessa Johnson rather than execute the offensive possession Gottlieb had originally planned.
Johnson converted both free throws, extending South Carolina’s lead to 89-85 with 13 seconds remaining.
Southern Cal subsequently failed to score. Its final offensive possession ended with a missed three-point attempt, and South Carolina secured the rebound to complete the victory.
Lindsay Gottlieb Questions the Timeout Situation
Following the game, Gottlieb recognized South Carolina’s ability to execute during important moments but raised concerns about the consequences of the replay decision.
During her opening postgame comments, she specifically questioned why Southern Cal was not given its timeout back after the original possession ruling was overturned.
“I just watched the last (play). … The first thing is, I’m unclear when I called the timeout that they’re allowed to review and it still costs me the timeout,” Gottlieb said. “If anyone has the answer on that, I’d like to know.”
Her frustration centered on the fact that she had requested the timeout based on the officials’ original ruling that Southern Cal would retain possession.
Once the replay changed that decision, the Trojans were left without the timeout they had used to prepare their intended offensive play.
ABC Broadcast Explains the Consequences of the Decision
The situation also became a major discussion point during ABC’s broadcast.
Play-by-play commentator Ryan Ruocco acknowledged how significantly the timeout situation affected Southern Cal’s final opportunity.
He described the timeout as “incredibly consequential.”
Ruocco also explained why the Trojans were not awarded another timeout after the review.
“Because USC used the timeout, they no longer have one to be able to advance the basketball on a subsequent offensive possession,” Ruocco said. “So just an unfortunate turn for USC where they think they’re using a timeout to draw up an offensive play.”
He continued:
“Instead, what happens is they give South Carolina time to review it, and now they won’t have one because they’re not awarded it back. They’d already used it.”
Analyst Rebecca Lobo also highlighted the difficulty of preparing for an offensive play without knowing that the possession decision would change.
“And they probably don’t know that this is going to be turned in South Carolina’s favor,” analyst Rebecca Lobo added. “You’re drawing up an (underneath) inbound play when ultimately you’re going to be taking it full court.”
Ruocco summarized Southern Cal’s unfortunate circumstances by saying:
“This one just feels unlucky for them,” Ruocco said.
Why Officials Overturned the Original Decision
The replay review became particularly important because of what officials determined after examining the final moments of the play.
Slow-motion footage showed Lee blocking Watkins’ attempt while Watkins maintained contact with the ball in the air.
The replay appeared to show the ball making its final contact with Watkins’ fingers before going out of bounds.
The officials, ABC’s broadcast team and the game’s rules analyst, Dee Kantner, all concluded that the available footage supported South Carolina receiving possession.
Following the review, an official announced that there was “clear and conclusive evidence” that Watkins had touched the ball last.
South Carolina’s successful challenge required Staley to use a timeout to initiate the coach’s appeal.
Staley subsequently credited the preparation and awareness of the program’s director of women’s basketball video services, Hudson Jacobs, for recognizing the opportunity to challenge the decision. She also acknowledged his wife.
After successfully overturning the call, Staley used the restored timeout again to advance the basketball to midcourt.
South Carolina then inbounded successfully to Johnson, who converted two free throws to establish the final four-point margin.
Lindsay Gottlieb Maintains That the Decision Was Close
Gottlieb later explained that she had reviewed the footage several times and believed Southern Cal had a reasonable argument for retaining possession.
She emphasized that overturning an original ruling should require particularly convincing video evidence.
“It has to be overwhelmingly conclusive to go the other way,” she said. “… It was close. It was really close. It’s a tough call, so then you go with the way that it was. That said, we had opportunities to be better at certain areas, and we will get better.”
Her comments reflected disappointment with the final decision, although she also acknowledged that Southern Cal had other opportunities to improve its performance during the game.
The Trojans ultimately finished with an 85-point effort but could not overcome South Carolina’s late execution.
JuJu Watkins Focuses on Moving Forward
JuJu Watkins, who led Southern Cal with 25 points, also addressed the disputed possession after the game.
Watkins shot 8-for-20 from the field and acknowledged that she could have been more aware during the closing sequence.
Rather than allowing the overturned call to dominate her postgame assessment, she emphasized the importance of accepting the result and concentrating on the next opportunity.
“I think that’s on me just having an awareness,” Watkins said. “And also, it’s like, ‘Next play.’ What happened, happened. We just move on.”
Her response demonstrated a different perspective from the frustration expressed by her head coach.
What the Result Means for Both Programs
South Carolina improved to 4-0, while Southern Cal dropped to 3-1 following the nationally significant matchup.
The victory provided another valuable result for Dawn Staley’s team as it continues building its NCAA Tournament résumé.
For Southern Cal, the defeat highlighted areas that need attention, particularly executing during the final possessions of closely contested games.
The replay controversy will remain an important talking point, but the outcome also reflected South Carolina’s ability to capitalize on a critical defensive play and convert its late free throws.
Ultimately, the overturned out-of-bounds decision changed the final possession, but South Carolina still had to execute its challenge, inbound successfully and make the free throws to secure the victory.
The Gamecocks accomplished those tasks, preserving their unbeaten record while handing the Trojans their first loss of the season.
